Messageboard

Oliver Stone: The Untold History of the United States

The Battle of Kursk

Posted by history-admin on 30 January 2008


The largest tank battle in history. The Germans aim to capture 66 Soviet divisions fails as the battle becomes one of attrition. Germany accepts a tactical draw and withdraws.



What are your thoughts of this battle?

13 replies so far...

  1. dsperanza

    11:49 PM, 07 June 2011

    Who knowns what might have happened if Hitler didn't take control of the German Wehrmacht. Kursk could have possibly had a different outcome. Hitler removed his Tanks to Europe which turned the tide of the battle at Kursk. His blunders cost the the war starting from the decision not to take Moscow and not letting his soldiers brake out of Stalingrad. In 1941 when they attacked Russia they were so powerful and professional, things would have been very different if he didn't run his country to the ground and take over the decisions of his experienced generals.

  2. Grahame217

    10:05 AM, 06 May 2008

    In fact, the T34, KV1 and Tiger predated the Kursk battle - the German timetable had been delayed by teething problems with the Panther and this vacillation by Hitler and the Wehmarcht contributed to their eventual defeat. The T34 and KV1 had been improved, particularly the T34 with new designs of turret and upgunning. Kursk in many ways owes much to World War One 'attrition' than German 'blitzkrieg' - it was a meat grinder battle....tank versus tank....man versus man....a merciless killing ground that the Germans could not win. After Kursk, the fate of Germany was sealed.

  3. Alanawaters

    10:07 PM, 26 February 2008

    Kursk was the definitive battle of the War.Its a pity that your broadcast is so drowned out by sound effects ! One can not hear the narrator enough to enjoy (?) the show. You dont need to have massive sound effects to understand what went on...the biggest tank battle in history with the Germans losing.

  4. ericebel39

    9:35 PM, 25 February 2008

    This was the big one on the vital eastern front when Germany committed 17 refurbished panzer divisions and nearly a million men on both sides of the Kursk salient with the latest tanks to try to regain the strategic initiative after Stalingrad, Even Hitler said the thought of it turned his stomach. Zhukov said it was the panzers swansong. In terms of equipment and manpower it dwarfs anything done on the western front during the war .

  5. kkken007

    3:07 PM, 17 February 2008

    I feel that the battle of kursk to be the defining battle of WW11 as it was fought between two of the most powerfull land armies on the European continent,both of whom knew that to lose this battle was to lose the war.Here were two Goliaths ready to face off in one of the bitterest struggles, ready to wage all.Add to this the state of the art in new weapons(Tiger and panther for Germany) and (T34 and KV1 for Russia) and you have the greatest tank battle ever witnessed in history,ensuring that this battle was like none before.

  6. Griefmaker

    8:25 PM, 14 February 2008

    I have voted Kursk. It's either this or Stalingrad, nothing else in WW2 compares to these two battles. The reason i picked kursk is because of the units involved. Namely Hitler's most elite well equipped divisions of the 2nd SS Panzer Korps. 1st SS Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler, 2nd SS Panzer Das Reich and 3rd SS Panzer Totenkopf. There are no other units in the german army that have better equipment. Yet with all there skill and Elan they could not beat numbers. The soviats could just keep sending more men and materials in and shrug the losses off. After this battle there was no more major German victory, the road for the russians was open (a bloody, costly road) to Berlin. A titanic battle of Guards Vs SS that is most worthy of the title "Greatest Battle Of WW2"!

  7. woodie016

    8:58 PM, 13 February 2008

    This is the battle that broke the Germans back. The German Offensive ran out of Gas, and everything afterward was purely Defensive. I rate this Battle second only to the Battle of Britain.

  8. cataphract

    2:09 PM, 13 February 2008

    The most significant result of Kursk was the removal from the Germans of the strategic initiative for the remainder of the war. This loss applied not just to the eastern front, but to the entire strategic posture of Germany, which could now only re-act to Allied [West and East] initiatives with ever diminishing resources. This led directly to the defeat of the Nazis, and, as a consequence, assured the subsequent fall of Japan. After Kursk Allied victory was assured. Now that's a great and most significant battle!

  9. militaryhistorian

    12:22 AM, 12 February 2008

    The Battle of Kursk was the biggest tank battle ever fought and resulted in heavy losses in tanks and troops on both sides. The difference was that Russia had ample resources in reserve, whereas Germany was fast running out of resources.

  10. nacional

    5:29 PM, 03 February 2008

    Stalingrad and then Kursk are generally recognised as the turning points of Hitler's war in the East. However, I believe the failure to capture Moscow in the autumn of 1941 as a result of prioritising Kiev and the whole of the Ukraine as the main obective (instead of Moscow, along with the initial encounters of two first-class Soviet tanks unknown to the Germans at that time, the T34 and KV1) as well as the subsequent siphoning of men and material from Army Group Centre to Army Group South for that operation was when the war was lost. We all know what happened next when Russia's two best generals December and January went over to the offensive. The German blitzkreig tactics were never meant to capture large areas, they were intended to focus the major effort on a singular objective. By the time Kursk came about, Germany was basically fighting a mobile retreat in the South and needed a limited victory to look as if it was at least gaining some of the strategic initiative on the Eastern Front. Stalin knew exactly what the German plan was as well as its jumping off date from the Lucy spy ring in Switzerland and warnings from British intelligence. This time Stalin listened to his generals' advice and decided to defend the Kursk salient (instead of his usually tactics of going over to the offensive) and bleed the Germans dry in a fruitless effort against multiple well-prepared defensive lines. When Hitler canclled the Kursk operation a week later, partly as a reaction to an Allied land in Sicily, The German Army had suffered armour losses that could never be made up again and from that point proceeded to embark on a two-year retreat that took the Red Army right into the heart of the Beast's lair.

  11. alamein1

    4:22 PM, 03 February 2008

    Without doubt the outcome of the Second World War was determined on the eastern front. The sheer size of the combatants and the immense destruction wrought on both sides, towers over any other theatre during the war. Kursk was the definitive battle on the eastern front. Germany lost the initiative after this battle and only engaged in fighting retreats until the downfall of the nazi regime.

  12. SciFiTragic

    11:13 PM, 02 February 2008

    Kursk was the turning point. There were millions of soldiers with thousands of tanks facing each other in battle. After Kursk, the Wehrmacht never launched another major attack on the Eastern Front. Germany could not match the manpower or equipment needs to fight the Soviets. That defines an important battle!

  13. ancientaustin

    8:55 PM, 02 February 2008

    I feel that the battle of Kursk was the first major loss to Nazi Germany on their 'Russian front' (eastern front). I don't feel that Nazi Germany ever recovered from this point on the (eastern front), and I believe was a major contribution to the downfall of Nazi occupied Eastern Europe.

Reply to this Topic

The History Channel Message Board is an exclusive place for Community Members.

You must be logged in to post a comment. If you are a member you can Log In Now

If you don't have an account you can become a member now, registration is free.

Back to top